Swan River polluted?

Grave fears for iconic Swan River dolphin pod after six deaths
JANE HAMMOND and ANGELA POWNALL, The West Australian November 14, 2009, 10:50 am

WA News / John Mokrzycki ©

The health of the Swan River has come under serious question after researchers revealed that dolphins that died in the waterway were found to have high levels of the banned chemical dieldrin.

A report into the deaths says the levels of dieldrin are among the highest found in marine mammals anywhere in the world.

Photos of the dead mammals show shocking skins lesions, growths and discolouration.

Of the six dolphins found dead since June, two were in such a state of decomposition that they could not be tested for contaminants.

Three of the dead dolphins were found to have high levels of contaminants including dieldrin, polychlorinated biphenyls, DDE and Zinc. A report by Murdoch University researchers on the deaths released today noted that little was known about the cumulative impact of mixtures of contaminants on the health of marine mammals.

Three of the mammals died in June and another three in September-October.

Lee Bell from the National Toxics Network said the contamination indicated that the dolphins were picking up chemicals that persisted in the environment.

He said up to 20 former landfill sites along the Swan River could be leaching poisons into the waterway and the spike in contaminants likely to result from dredging in the Fremantle Port in January could spell the end to the river’s dolphin population.

“When you get marine mammals already suffering from high levels of contaminants and you add more to the mix it can be the straw that breaks the camel’s back,” Mr Bell said.

He said both humans and dolphins could take up dieldrin though the skin as well as through eating contaminated fish.

Leading marine biologist Jean Paul Orsini backed Mr Bell's calls saying the threat to the dolphins from Fremantle Port's planned dredging program was too great, especially given the already vacarious state of the pod's health.

Shadow Environment Minister Sally Talbot warned swimmers, water sports lovers and people who eat fish and seafood out of the Swan River that their health could be affected.

She called on the Government to hold an urgent inquiry into the deaths of a nearly quarter of the iconic Swan River dolphins in the past five months and the presence of dieldrin in the water.

“This is very distressing news. It’s not just about the six dead dolphins in five months. It’s about the fact that half of them appear to have been killed by dieldrin. Dieldrin is one most poisonous chemicals we have known in this country and that’s why it was banned more than 20 years ago,” Ms Talbot said.

“We have no way of knowing it is a risk to humans. If there is indeed dieldrin in the Swan River, then that’s a very, very serious thing. The impact is not just upon people who like to fish and eat what they catch, but water-skiers, swimmers and anybody using our waterways.”

Ms Talbot added that she wouldn’t swim in the river herself, but it was up to people to decide that for themselves.

Environment Minister Donna Faragher said the Swan River was safe to swim in and there was no health risk from eating river fish.

“The Government has been advised by fisheries and health agencies that there is no direct risk to the public by swimming in, or by consuming any fish caught in the Swan and Canning rivers," Ms Faragher said.

"The deaths share many of the same features observed in dolphins studied elsewhere in the world."

Murdoch University researchers in collaboration with the Swan River Trust, Department of Environment and Conservation and Curtin University have investigating the dolphin deaths.

An urgent meeting of researchers and government agencies this week discussed the findings of post-mortem examinations of the dolphins.

Murdoch University wildlife biologist Dr Hugh Finn said the dead dolphins were likely to have been regular users of the Swan and Canning rivers and part of a resident community of about 20-25 dolphins.

"The deaths of the Swan River dolphins share many of the same features observed in significant mortalities of dolphins studied elsewhere in the world, including evidence of suppressed immune systems and bacterial, fungal and virus infection," he said on the ABC’s Stateline program last night.

"Entanglement in discarded fishing line is also a contributing factor, with one dolphin dying as a result of an infection arising from entanglement around its tail flukes and a second dolphin suffering from entanglement around a pectoral fin and a fish hook lodged in its oesophagus."

Two of the dead dolphins were females of a reproductive age, and two had severe skin lesions.

Murdoch veterinary pathologist Dr Nahiid Stephens told ABC TV that the post-mortem examinations indicate that immunosuppression was evident in at least four of the dolphin deaths.

"This may be attributable to a range of factors, including viral infection, rapid seasonal changes in water quality, and long-term exposure to contaminants," Dr Stephens said.

"In comparison to contaminant levels reported in dolphins internationally, concentrations of dieldrin were high in tissues from three dead dolphins that were analysed for the presence of variety of contaminants," she said.

A spokeswoman for Murdoch University said researchers were working on a range of further tests to investigate the post-mortem findings and would be looking at whether an as yet unidentified marine mammal pathogen may be present, such as Cetacean Morbillivirus, a virus known to cause immunosuppression.


Leemo's picture

Posts: 3712

Date Joined: 22/02/07

was at the canning bridge

Sat, 2009-11-14 20:16

was at the canning bridge today and usually see at least a small pod of them, but just saw the one. thort it a bit wierd to just see one herding fish by itself. not good for the river at all.!!!

____________________________________________________________________________

bludgin' since 94'

wopjrb's picture

Posts: 1407

Date Joined: 05/03/09

nott good to see

Sat, 2009-11-14 20:31

maybe we should go back to living like cavemen in the forest

Albee Mangles's picture

Posts: 985

Date Joined: 20/05/08

Why would you?

Sat, 2009-11-14 22:24

I mean screw that, who would want to have to hunt, fish and gather all day, then head home and gorge on fresh food living in a cave with my woman and family...

Matt T's picture

Posts: 875

Date Joined: 19/11/07

Sh*t

Sat, 2009-11-14 22:35

Those pics look horrible. Doesn't not paint a good picture of the river.

Posts: 1081

Date Joined: 30/03/08

Dieldren for the people who

Sun, 2009-11-15 09:06

Dieldren for the people who dont know was used years ago under houses as a pesticide for termites etc.

I wonder how much these chemicals effect other life in the system such as prawns?

Using the river as a sewerage drain doesnt sound like best practice.

It just shows you.  The river may appear clean but its far from healthy.

 

____________________________________________________________________________

Angling tourism is worth $10 billion to the Australian economy - 90000 jobs; more than any sport; spread the word

HuggyB's picture

Posts: 2515

Date Joined: 03/08/08

enjoy

Sun, 2009-11-15 10:27

that fresh Swan Mulloway!

____________________________________________________________________________

                    The Terrorist - coming to a fishing spot near you.........

gregk's picture

Posts: 169

Date Joined: 03/02/09

thats bad

Sun, 2009-11-15 10:56

i wouldnt be eating anything from the swan but you gota feel sorry for the dolphins and every thing eles that lives in there

Posts: 2321

Date Joined: 03/05/06

differing opinions

Sun, 2009-11-15 18:22

I cannot understand how there can be such extreme difference of opinion as to the health of the Swan when we see appallingly ulcerated and dead dolphins caused by, among other chemicals, absolutely deadly dieldren (to both humans and wildlife) but the Health Minister says no, everything's good, eat, swim.  I'd certainly be erring on the side of caution.  Take another look at those pics.

Posts: 1081

Date Joined: 30/03/08

that fresh Swan

Mon, 2009-11-16 09:57

that fresh Swan Mulloway!

The fish that ate the crab that sat n the mud Foot in mouth

My grandmother ate fish from the river.  Her mercury levels were through the roof when they tested her after she had died at 59.   Even Cockburn sound Id be scepticle even though things have improved.  

International shipping and mussel farms in the same vicinity. Ya can stick that up ya red rum.

____________________________________________________________________________

Angling tourism is worth $10 billion to the Australian economy - 90000 jobs; more than any sport; spread the word

Tony Halliday's picture

Posts: 2500

Date Joined: 14/06/07

but we all want cheap pretty

Mon, 2009-11-16 10:44

but we all want cheap pretty houses with quick green grass hey!!!
We let developers bulldoze the native plants, trees and grass's into huge piles and burn them off... why??? cause you all want roses and pansies in your gardens, oh and you want perfect fruit with no marks or worm holes...
Well thats the price we pay,
nothing wrong with native plants, trees and native grass lands, so what if my apple has a fruit fly mark? never killed my grandad, so why should I not eat it.

oh as for pesticides, Australia is still in the dark ages! yes...very dark ages, they don't even want to let in an eco-safe pesticide like BioKill from Jesmond Biocides Europe, that only kills cold blooded animals, bio-degrades and if your kid picked up a bottle and drank it, it would not harm him.
( I was the South African agent for it and tried to bring it to Australia,,, too much red tape and too hard. no matter how safe it is, they will stick to their old deadly ways.)
www.jesmond.com go read about this stuff!
http://www.jesmond.com/bk_normal.html

I drank 2 litres of it at a conference to prove how safe it is, yet the Australian regulatory authority has soo much red tape it would be un-economical to redo all the world wide research to get it into such a small market, oh well you still have DDT hey...

____________________________________________________________________________

Tony Halliday: ~Meals on Reels ~

 It takes a strong fish to swim against the current. Even a dead one can float with it

"It is always in season for old men to learn." Aeschylus (525-456 BC)

"In a mad world only the mad are sane." Akira Kurosawa (1910-1998)

hlokk's picture

Posts: 4293

Date Joined: 04/04/08

Strange you would suggest a

Mon, 2009-11-16 11:21

Strange you would suggest a biocide that is extremely toxic to fish... (as, or more deadly than dieldrin to fish). Probably still safer than DDT in general though, but I'm not sure thats really all that liberally used anyways.

One other thing with the 'quick green grass' is the nitrogen and phosphates entering the waterways which contributes to undesirable algae as well :s. More natives would be good too see in more gardens, but people have their tastes and tend to stick to them I guess.

Tony Halliday's picture

Posts: 2500

Date Joined: 14/06/07

ahh you read half of

Mon, 2009-11-16 13:02

ahh you read half of it...
it's very toxic to fish when applied fresh, but once in a biological system, ie ground water, breaks down very fast.
the half life and LDO 50 of poisons are what count and do they accumulate in the system.

a product can be deadly to fish when freshly sprayed, yet once in the ground and reaching the water table say 24hrs later, it will have lost 90% of it's efficacy, not like many of the present toxins we use that are less effective on critters , but compound up and still are deadly weeks later.
it's all about the balance and control.

cheers

____________________________________________________________________________

Tony Halliday: ~Meals on Reels ~

 It takes a strong fish to swim against the current. Even a dead one can float with it

"It is always in season for old men to learn." Aeschylus (525-456 BC)

"In a mad world only the mad are sane." Akira Kurosawa (1910-1998)

Adam Gallash's picture

Posts: 15665

Date Joined: 29/11/05

lol

Mon, 2009-11-16 11:19

So that explains a few things then. lol.  Tongue out

____________________________________________________________________________

Site Admin - Just ask if you need assistance

Posts: 1081

Date Joined: 30/03/08

Interesting points Klokk. 

Mon, 2009-11-16 12:53

Interesting points Klokk.  One thing that could help is the acceleration of plantings that have already occurred.  There was some pretty big swamp lands around the Narrows prior to its construction which would uptake some of the nutrients.

The construction of nitrogen stripping ponds prior to their entry of the Swan would help also.  It is estimated that some 40% enters the Swan via the Ellenbrook stream.  Imagine dramatically reducing that amount by building stripping ponds pre-entry tot he Swan?.

Bunbury has mangroves I believe. I wonder if that species existed in the Swan prior to settlement.  However mangroves have some of the highest nutrient stripping value in the estuarine systems.  Their removal would have a substantial impact to the current sad state of affairs that occurs.

The Swan riparian zone is virtually non existent in some areas built up by stone retaining to prevent boat wake eroding the banks and of course some is land reclamation for construction.

We no longer have large trees forming structure in the system around developed areas.

You have to wonder how all thee chemicals impact things like Mulloway/Bream spawn etc?

No doubt  massive reconstruction of riparian zones are need along with the stripping ponds to alleviate the extra nutrient that enters our waterways.

More sunken tree structure, more geo-mat with plantings, more stripping systems are needed.

The Avon is a green sess pool in summer.  Here is a picture of York.  It once had many large trees and riparian regions until it was cleared due to threat fo flooding the town.

Oh, dont forget the faeces overflow to the Swan by one o f the highest profit government alias corp departments in our wonderful worlds best practice policy. Frown

All this crap by conservationists about the protection of endemic Glaxia threat from trans-located species such as trout and we treat the rivers like this?

When you look at all the focus on recreational extraction reduction.

How hypocritically politically ****** up our flora and fauna management philosophy is... 

____________________________________________________________________________

Angling tourism is worth $10 billion to the Australian economy - 90000 jobs; more than any sport; spread the word

Posts: 1081

Date Joined: 30/03/08

but we all want cheap pretty

Mon, 2009-11-16 13:26

but we all want cheap pretty houses with quick green grass hey!!!
We let developers bulldoze the native plants, trees and grass's into huge piles and burn them off... why??? cause you all want roses and pansies in your gardens, oh and you want perfect fruit with no marks or worm holes...
Well thats the price we pay,
nothing wrong with native plants, trees and native gra

We dont have cheap houses, cheap buildings is only absorbed by a rising cost of land as it is only what people can afford that drives the price of property. Now we have cheap poor inefficient insulated homes with expensive land.

oh as for pesticides, Australia is still in the dark ages! yes...very dark ages, they don't even want to let in an eco-safe pesticide like BioKill from Jesmond Biocides Europe, that only kills cold blooded animals, bio-degrades and if your kid picked up a bottle and drank it, it would not harm him.

Not quite, this is what is used today for many aspects of pesticide.  However it tends to make tradesmen vomit more when its sprayed than in the past on nearby construction.

Dieldren may have been buried at waste sites when it was banned.  There must be a source somewhere and one would hope the Swan river trust tracks entrance points through their water quality management program.

Really what is needed also is more Henderson Island ponds also, along with the run off of water quality around Burswood Golf course etc where river water runs in which must be surely monitored now?

 

____________________________________________________________________________

Angling tourism is worth $10 billion to the Australian economy - 90000 jobs; more than any sport; spread the word

7739ian's picture

Posts: 948

Date Joined: 25/06/08

Thats not good

Mon, 2009-11-16 14:45

but you should have a look at the Vasse River in the centre of Busselton - as green as Alfreds Kitchen pea soup and a whole lot thicker. No wonder people drive on through to Augusta and Margs.